If I really need to get home on a specific day and don’t have loads of overall flexibility, ordinarily I’ll be able to find cheap flights on this route whatever the season. I use Skyscanner Pretty much solely. I’ve in no way heard about the ITA Matrix, just checked it https://erickazxso.illawiki.com/1492545/new_step_by_step_map_for_how_to_find_cheap_flights_to_europe_from_the_us